Gas vs. electric ranges: all you need to know

Based on 4,474 opinions
Our winners are
1 of 5

Gas or electric ranges? This question is asked by multiple thousands of users from across the web on a daily basis. Buzzrake collected over 4,000 opinions on numerous gas and electric models to discover which type of stove is favored among users. Based on user opinions, electric stoves receive higher customer satisfaction ratings. The 9 Overall Best Ranges are all electric as well. Nonetheless, gas ranges have some strong points as well, and there are definitely some issues to consider before making your choice:

  1. Price and cost-efficiency: gas stoves are sold for about $200 more than electric ones on average, and have the added cost of installation. However, in most states gas is significantly cheaper than electricity, meaning that a gas range will cost you much less in the long-run.
  2. Cleanup: according to users, gas ranges are far more difficult to clean, which is not surprising - disassembling and working your way around gas burners can be a hassle. Electric ranges, particularly smooth-top models, are reportedly much easier to maintain in terms of cleanup; a simple wipe is usually enough to take care of most spills.
  3. Safety: open flames and gas leaks are major safety hazards, as they can lead to fires. Electric ranges are much safer to use in that aspect. Electric stove-tops often have a "still hot" indicator light, reminding you that the surface can remain dangerously hot for a while after it is shut off. If you're opting for an electric model, make sure to choose one with this safety feature to reduce the risk of burns.
  4. Ease of use: gas ranges consistently receive better scores for this factor. As the burners provide a direct flame, you don't have to wait for them to reach the desired temperature. This type of burners allow more control over the heat - and there is immediate visual confirmation. They also respond much faster when the flame is reduced or turned off, unlike electric cook-tops.

Bottom line: it's all a matter of what you're looking for in a stove. Check out our round-up of the best electric and best gas ranges to help you decide what model is best for your kitchen.

The Best Ranges on the Market

Buzzrake collected thousands of opinions from across the web to determine which are the best ranges sold on the market. A cumulative score was calculated for each product, and the Top 5 products below have the highest scores, regardless of fuel type.
#1 rated in gas vs. electric: Whirlpool Freestanding Electric Convection Range, scored 100/100100

1. Whirlpool Freestanding Electric Convection Range

According to user opinions, the Whirlpool Freestanding Electric Convection Range is the #1 gas_vs_electric. It has a total capacity of 6.2 cubic feet. The cooktop features 5 heating elements. Users consider the cooktop and oven very easy to operate and and rate them very highly for usability. Opinions indicate that the range performs terrifically and that it typically delivers excellent results. In addition, when it comes to design, most users find this range rather appealing.
Learn more


#2 rated in gas vs. electric: Frigidaire Freestanding Electric Range, scored 95/10094

2. Frigidaire Freestanding Electric Range

According to users, the Frigidaire Freestanding Electric Range is the #2 gas_vs_electric. It has a total capacity of 4.8 cubic feet. The stovetop features 4 heating elements. As far as looks go, the majority of users think that this range is rather appealing. This range receives exceptionally high scores for overall value. However, users consider the cooktop and oven just fairly easy to use and give them an average score for usability.
Learn more


#3 rated in gas vs. electric: Samsung Slide-In Electric Double-Oven Convection Range, scored 95/10094

3. Samsung Slide-In Electric Double-Oven Convection Range

The Samsung Slide-In Electric Double-Oven Convection Range is the #3 gas_vs_electric. It has a total capacity of 5.8 cubic feet. The cooktop features 5 elements. Opinions show that the range's performance is spectacular and that it typically delivers excellent results. In terms of style, most users find this range very appealing. In addition, most users are quite pleased with this product.
Learn more


#4 rated in gas vs. electric: Whirlpool Freestanding Electric Range, scored 94/10093

4. Whirlpool Freestanding Electric Range

The Whirlpool Freestanding Electric Range was chosen by users as the #4 gas_vs_electric. It has a total capacity of 4.8 cubic feet. The stovetop includes 4 heating elements. When it comes to looks, most users think that this range is rather attractive. Users are extremely satisfied with it. In addition, this stove receives great marks for overall value.
Learn more


#5 rated in gas vs. electric: Whirlpool Freestanding Gas Range, scored 92/10091

5. Whirlpool Freestanding Gas Range

The Whirlpool Freestanding Gas Range is the #5 gas_vs_electric. It has a total capacity of 5 cubic feet. The cooktop includes 4 heating elements. Most owners are very happy with this model. This stove is rated high for value. However, this unit is rated around average for easy cleanup.
Learn more