How to find a grill that's a workhorse

Based on 2,811 opinions
Our winners are
1 of 5

Do you barbecue often? Do you host backyard parties and flip 50 patties in a given Saturday afternoon? If this sounds like you, you're probably looking for a grill that can take a beating. Not all can; some warp, rust, fall apart all too soon leaving you stuck on no notice. How will you know which grills are heavy duty and which are not?
You could read a bunch of online reviews, but how about an analysis of thousands of reviews that basically does all the work for you? Buzzrake collected user opinions from across the web to find out what makes some grills more durable than others, and which grills leave all the others behind. We have found the following:

  • Pricey models tend to be more durable. When it comes to grills, you really are getting more for your money. Grills that cost upwards of $280 had the highest durability ratings on average.
  • Propane grills are more durable than charcoal ones on average. That shouldn't be a huge surprise, as charcoal grills get handled far more by the use, and parts get removed and put back together more often for filling and cleanup.
  • High BTU = higher durability. This probably goes together with high price, as we have seen that more expensive units tend to offer higher BTU ratings.
  • Durability goes hand in hand with other great features like high quality, quick start up, and satisfying grill features. The grills rated highest for durability are really a win-win for almost everything else.

The top rated brands for durability are Kingsford, Fuego, Char-Griller and Cuisinart. Weber and Dyna-Glo aren't far behind ,either. The bottom rated brands for durability are Coleman and Bayou Classic.

Check out our list of the top rated products for durability.

Top 5 Most Durable Grills

#1 rated in durable: XL Guide Gear Heavy-Duty Park-Style Grill, scored 98/10098

1. XL Guide Gear Heavy-Duty Park-Style Grill

The XL Guide Gear Heavy-Duty Park-Style Grill is considered the #1 best durable grill. This grill is almost entirely intuitive to use . You might not be able to assemble this unit by yourself. However, its customer satisfaction scores are around average compared to other grills on the market.
Learn more


#2 rated in durable: Weber Genesis E-330 3-Burner Copper Propane Gas Grill, scored 98/10098

2. Weber Genesis E-330 3-Burner Copper Propane Gas Grill

Users chose the Weber Genesis E-330 3-Burner Copper Propane Gas Grill as the #2 best durable grill. The temperature control is described as smooth. Its customer satisfaction ratings are pretty high compared to other grills on the market. However, users report that this unit's performance is nothing to write home about and it usually delivers fair results.
Learn more


#3 rated in durable: Portable Kitchen PK 99740 Cast Aluminum Grill and Smoker, scored 97/10096

3. Portable Kitchen PK 99740 Cast Aluminum Grill and Smoker

Users consider the Portable Kitchen PK 99740 Cast Aluminum Grill and Smoker the #3 most durable grill. Its customer satisfaction scores are rather high in comparison to other grills on the market. This grill is not entirely intuitive to use . However, you will have trouble to assemble this model by yourself.
Learn more


#4 rated in durable: Weber One Touch Gold 22.5 Inch Charcoal Grill, scored 95/10094

4. Weber One Touch Gold 22.5 Inch Charcoal Grill

The Weber One Touch Gold 22.5 Inch Charcoal Grill is rated the #4 best durable grill. When it comes to cleaning, opinions show that this unit is not a problem to clean. The setup process is said to be standard. However, users report that it's performance is nothing to write home about and it consistently delivers fair results.
Learn more


#5 rated in durable: Weber 4421001 Spirit E-310 LP Gas Grill, scored 95/10094

5. Weber 4421001 Spirit E-310 LP Gas Grill

The Weber 4421001 Spirit E-310 LP Gas Grill is the #5 most durable grill. Usere feel that they have very sufficient control over the temperature. You could definitely assemble this product on your own. Also, its customer satisfaction scores are extremely high compared to other grills on the market.
Learn more